Education benefits are widespread among large employers, but not all employers see the workforce outcomes they were hoping for when it comes to education benefits programs.
According to research commissioned by EdAssist® by Bright Horizons® and conducted by HR Dive, 83% of senior HR and talent leaders say their education benefits actively support their organization's talent strategy. 82% also say those programs help fill critical or hard-to-fill roles.
But the employer perspective and the employee experience tell very different stories. The 2026 Bright Horizons Education Index, found that while 83% of working learners are motivated to build new skills, 47% don't know where to begin. And only 40% report that their new skills actually helped them advance their career.
Employees are motivated to learn and employers are investing in education benefits, but the breakdown happens in the structure connecting the two. This disconnect represents a significant and often invisible drag on workforce ROI. We call that internal mobility block the “mobility cliff.”
What the mobility cliff costs employers
The mobility cliff describes what happens when employees complete training and develop new skills, but that learning never translates into career movement. This often happens because there's no clear pathway connecting workforce education and internal talent development to internal opportunities.
When employees invest time and effort in upskilling and reskilling, but can’t see it lead anywhere, employee engagement drops. The Education Index found that 77% of employees would prefer to stay with their current employer if clear internal advancement opportunities existed, but only if they’re engaged. Gallup reported that engagement fell to its lowest level since 2011 and that the employees report less clarity about what’s expected of them.
While engagement and internal mobility is exactly what your education benefits program should offer, this retention ROI only works if career pathways are visible and connected to the education programs employees are completing. Without that connection, employers lose the people they just invested in developing, despite the clear upskilling strategy in place.
When those employees leave, employers lose twice. They lose the tuition dollars they invested in developing that person, and they lose the institutional knowledge that person carried. An employee who has been with your organization and built relationships with your clients brings context that a new external hire has to build from scratch.
That's the real cost of a mobility cliff: you funded the learning, but someone else benefits from the talent.
Why the mobility cliff is structural
One of the clearest findings across both the research studies is that disconnected learning systems are structural but can’t be fixed in a silo.
How program catalogs create analysis paralysis for employees
Education benefits are typically structured as catalogs. Employees can browse a list of schools, degrees, and certifications. This sounds helpful, but in reality, the programs are organized by provider and subject instead of by career pathway or business need.
Dr. Cali Morrison, Senior Director of Workforce Education Strategy at EdAssist® by Bright Horizons, calls this “analysis paralysis.” Employees are presented with an abundance of choices but no framework for understanding which choices connect to the roles their employer needs to fill. So, while students do see what their learning options are, they don’t have a good understanding of which programs could help them excel in their career.
Bright Horizons’ research, Dynamics of Corporate Education Benefits: Is Your Program Built for What's Next?, confirms this from the employer side. When asked what single improvement would have the greatest impact on their education benefits program, HR leaders most often identified clearer alignment between coursework and internal career pathways. And that's despite 89% of organizations surveyed reporting that they already have defined career pathways.
This means that the career pathways may exist, but they're just not connected to the education benefit in a way employees can see and move forward.
Why internal mobility conversations aren't happening at scale
Managers play a critical role in connecting employees to learning opportunities and helping them understand how those opportunities map to their career. But the data shows that connection is happening far less often than it needs to.
Only 33% of employees reported having a conversation with their manager about building relevant skills in the past year. Meanwhile, 80% of employees want confirmation from their employer that they're on the right track, building the skills that will actually lead to advancement.
Our corporate education benefits research adds context to why this disconnect keeps happening when businesses invest in developing internal talent.
Education benefits typically sit within a single function, most commonly L&D (46% of respondents) or Benefits and Total Rewards (36%). Talent management owns the program in fewer than one in five organizations. When program goals and reporting are confined to one team's priorities, the organization struggles to capture impact metrics like internal mobility, skills progression, and readiness to fill priority roles.
The result is that the people closest to employees' day-to-day work, their managers, often don't have the information or the tools to guide career development conversations. And the teams managing the education benefit don't always have visibility into the workforce planning data that would make those programs more strategic.
How cost and time barriers limit education benefits participation
Even when employees are motivated and programs are available, structural barriers prevent participation. The research conducted by HR Dive found that the top obstacles holding employees back from using education benefits are:
- 81% reported a lack of time
- 33% said the approval process felt too daunting or complex
- 26% said a lack of awareness about the benefit was a top obstacle
Cost remains the most significant barrier for working learners. The Education Index found that 53% of employees said knowing they would incur student loan debt has prevented them from pursuing additional education. And the financial barrier extends beyond tuition. Employees also face the opportunity cost of time spent learning while working and caring for family members.
There are 43.1 million adults in the U.S. with some college and no degree. Many of them stopped out for exactly these reasons. A benefit that relies on employees to pay upfront and get reimbursed later may never reach the frontline workers who would benefit the most.
What the data says about programs that actually drives workforce outcomes
Bright Horizons research conducted by HR Dive also looked at what distinguishes high-performing education benefits programs. Three patterns stand out.
How high-performing programs measure workforce outcomes beyond completion
Participation and completion are the most commonly tracked metrics for education benefits, with eight in 10 employers tracking completion rates. But roughly half of surveyed employers are now tracking five or more KPIs to evaluate their programs. The impact metrics gaining traction include employee retention, tracked by roughly six in 10 respondents, and internal mobility, tracked by roughly five in 10.
The shift matters because completion rates alone don't tell you whether education investments are translating into workforce outcomes. An employee can complete a program and still hit an internal mobility cliff if there's no pathway connecting that credential to an internal opportunity.
How leading employers remove barriers to education benefits participation
Best-in-class programs prioritize accessibility. They address the time, financial, and administrative obstacles that prevent employees from participating in the first place.
The research highlights several approaches leading employers are using. Some have moved to direct billing, where the employer pays the institution directly, so employees face no upfront costs. Others have simplified the approval process, expanded access to no-cost education options, and offered both traditional and self-paced online formats to accommodate varying schedules.
Several EdAssist customers have already done this. A large healthcare system, for example, introduced an expedited ESL program for non-English speakers that could be completed in half the time of traditional programs, with no cost to the employee. And a financial services organization shifted to a skills-first approach, allowing employees to build in-demand skills through shorter, applied learning experiences without committing to multi-year degree programs.
How strategic programs connect learning to in-demand roles
The most effective programs don't start by asking "what should we offer?" They start by asking "what capabilities do we need?" and design education pathways backward from there.
The data from the research conducted by HR Dive shows that 41% of employers selected workforce reskilling as their top priority for the next 12 months, ahead of career advancement (24%) and talent retention (20%). When asked which skills matter most, the top priorities were:
- Role-specific skills (53%)
- Critical thinking (48%)
- AI readiness (44%)
- Collaboration and teamwork (42%)
- Data and analytics (38%)
- Leadership (36%)
Among EdAssist clients, programs that connect education directly to these priority areas are seeing measurable results:
- A large healthcare employer expanded debt-free education access to part-time and per-diem staff and saw a 92% retention rate for participating employees, with a 14% increase in retention compared to baseline.
- A quick-service food retailer saw 30% of employees in its education program receive promotions after starting a degree.
- A financial services client saw a 97% retention rate after launching a targeted skills program, with utilization increasing 22% year over year on only a 10% increase in investment.
Download the research to see what leaders reveal about corporate education benefits today.
How employers can connect learning to career movement
Closing the mobility cliff requires more than adding new programs to the catalog. It requires connecting education benefits to career pathways, workforce planning, and manager engagement in ways that make advancement visible and navigable for employees.
Employers looking to strengthen that connection should consider:
- Mapping education programs to defined career pathways so employees can see how a credential connects to their next role within the organization
- Starting with workforce needs, not program catalogs. Ask what roles need to be filled and what skills are required, then build learning options backward from those priorities
- Supplementing manager coaching with professional guidance. With only 33% of employees receiving career development conversations from their managers, programs like EdAssist's coaching model can bridge that disconnect
- Tracking workforce outcomes alongside participation metrics. Completion rates are necessary but insufficient. Add internal mobility, time-to-fill for critical roles, and retention among participants to your measurement framework
- Removing financial and administrative barriers that prevent frontline employees from participating. Direct billing, simplified approvals, and no-cost options expand the talent piepline that benefits can actually reach
- Breaking down functional silos around program ownership. When education benefits are managed in isolation from talent management and workforce planning, the program's strategic potential is limited
Education benefits have earned a more strategic role. The challenge is that many programs haven't evolved to match that ambition.
The employers seeing the strongest workforce outcomes from their education investments are the ones connecting learning to career pathways, equipping employees with guidance and coaching, removing the barriers that block participation, and measuring what matters: whether people are actually moving into the roles the business needs.
The mobility cliff is a solvable problem. But solving it requires treating education benefits as a workforce strategy, one that's embedded in talent planning and career pathways rather than managed as a standalone line item in total rewards.
Request a conversation to explore how EdAssist can help you strategically connect learning investments to real workforce outcomes.